Who is more annoying?
 

Who do you think is more annoying- Eliza Jane or Carrie, why? :confused:

I think that Carrie and Eliza Jane are equally annoying. No reason in particular, they just are. Although, I would've put up with Eliza Janes annoyingness (if that's even a word) just to get close to Manly. ;)

Carrie character was not annoying to me. She was just a little kid. Why can't you guys get off of her character's case? In case you forgot, this show was about Laura Ingalls not Carrie. Lindsey & Sidney were supporting cast members, not the stars of the show. How do you think they would feel if they read all of the negative posts about their acting? How would you feel if it was you? They were little girls when this show aired, what did you expect from them? I'm sure they did exactly what Michael Landon expected of them, so back off.

I totally agree, it makes me really sad when you say bad thigs about Carrie and I´m sure its really bad to the twins, they always appear on the reunions and they seem just great, don´t deserve this...
For me Carrie is really sweet, specially on the first seasons when she was a baby.. she has soo cute! How can you ignore that? :(

I'm pretty neutral on the Carrie character. She was absolutely adorable when she was very small. Unfortunately, Lindsey & Sidney were not given very much in terms of script after Carrie got a bit older. She was more or less in the background, and that made it hard (for me as a viewer) to really get to know who she was as a character or develop any strong like or dislike for her. Why were the twins not given more material? Who knows. It is really anyone's guess. It seems pretty apparent to me that once the Cassandra character was brought on, Carrie's role became less and less. Was that a purposeful move on the part of the producers? I don't know. I know what I think, but that is just my opinion. We all have our opinions on the characters and the actors who played them.

To me, the character of Eliza Jane was hilarious, not annoying. I thought she was a hoot to watch, and Lucy Lee did a wonderful job with that role. Landon was fond of her and took pains to give her interesting material to play. She lucked out that way.

C

I like Carrie! She reminds me of my little sister; she can be anoyying at time but she is still my little loveing little sister.

I feel sorry for the Greenbush twins because I don't believe they were really given a chance. The character of Carrie just wasn't developed. In real life, Carrie and Laura were much closer and Laura seemed to take care of her (Carrie was a frail girl). Carrie was only 3 years younger than Laura, but on the TV show, she never really grew up. Instead of developing her character, they introduced James & Cassandra Cooper, who Charles and Caroline adopted after the children's parents were killed in a wagon accident. I don't think this was at all necessary since we should have been given a chance to get to know Carrie & Grace better. That, to me, is truly annoying.

Also, just to nitpick a little ... Grace wasn't a toddler when Laura was married. She was actually 8. Carrie was around 15, though on the TV show she looks to be around 10.

I know this isn't going to win many friends, but I'm sorry to say that Eliza Jane really annoyed me. Lucy Lee Flippen is so awkward-looking and tall (the real Eliza Jane was average-looking and short) and what's with her voice?? She also acts so prissy and dainty -- not at all like the homesteader (she had a claim shanty of her own) the real Eliza Jane was.

(Thanks for letting me vent! lol)

I don't care much for either character, but my vote goes to Eliza Jane. She looked like she was always sucking on lemons. And her voice/manners annoy me sometimes. :p

I think what I found annoying about Carrie was how they kept her in the baby voice and the baby lines. She really never did mature in her portrayal of the character. Compare her acting and character to Laura in the first season when she was really young. A world of difference!

Amy

Neither
 

Well, personally I like Eliza Jane. I think she is halerious! And as for Carrie, I have no problem with her, but she did always get the worst lines in the show. I mean in one episode (they show her a lot she just doesn't talk much) she was in almost in every scene, but her only line in the whole episode was:
No, Pa!
lol. I think if she was given a better part she would have turned out a great little actress.

I agree! The Greenbush twins get less credit (now and when they were on the show) then they deserve. Eliza Jane was really annoying especially in Days of Sunshine Days of Shadow. Though she did add a lot of humor to the show and I am sure the real actress, Lucy Lee Flippin is nice. But if you have ever read the LHOP books Eliza Jane is even more mean and annoying.

Hey all,
I didn't mean to start a big arguement about this I was just asking. I wasn't trying to be offensive about Carrie or Eliza but some people were like Carrie's annoying or Eliza Jane is annoying etc. Everyone is entitled to have their own opinion.

We weren't ever on her case to begin with. And we didn't forget that it was about PA, MA, MARY, LAURA, and CARRIE. EVERYONE IS ENTITLED TO HAVE THEIR OWN OPINION. :D

To mgilbertfan-
You're the only one who is arguing here. Capital letters imply that you are yelling and the fact that you used my quote above your note suggests that you are yelling at me. Is the smiley face at the end supposed to soften the blow?
Don't post if you can't handle the response.

I myself think that Carrie was a darling little actress. I wish that she would have had more parts and I think they could have had a lot of interesting storys about her. But sometimes they do tend to make her a little bit annoying with her one word responses that most of the time you cant understand. But that is not her fault its the writters. But she really doesn't bother me and she turned out to be a really pretty preteen in some of the older episodes.

Eliza Jane was a hoot. She was a strange little person in Walnut Grove but I think she made the show better.